Craft Notes | Fiction Writing
I was rereading one of my short stories recently when I realized something wasn't working.
I had everything a story was supposed to have: characters, conflict, tough decisions, and a plot that moved forward. In one particular scene, something happening outside was supposed to challenge my characters' morality. The situation was clear, and I knew exactly where everyone stood.
But something was missing.
I could tell readers what was happening. What I hadn't quite managed to do was make them feel what it meant to the people experiencing it.
My first instinct was to add more. Another conversation, a few lines of description, maybe some backstory to explain why the characters were behaving the way they were.
Except the scene didn't need more events. It needed more going on beneath the events already there.
What's Happening Beneath the Scene?
Imagine two siblings packing up their mother's apartment after her death.
We could write that they spent the afternoon sorting through her belongings, disagreeing over what to keep, and eventually finishing the kitchen.
There's nothing particularly wrong with that. It tells us what happened.
But consider this:
"Just throw those out," Lena said.
Her brother held up a chipped coffee mug. "Even this one?"
She pulled another strip of packing tape across a box that was already sealed.
Outside, the neighbor started mowing his lawn.
Now there's more to consider.
Maybe Lena is trying to get through the afternoon without becoming emotional. Perhaps her brother is having a harder time letting go. Or maybe they've spent years disagreeing about what matters, and an old coffee mug is simply the latest argument.
We don't know yet, and we don't need to.
Their conversation is about a mug. Their behavior suggests something else. Meanwhile, the neighbor is going about his afternoon, completely unaffected by what this family is experiencing.
Several things are happening in the same moment, and each gives the scene a little more weight.
Looking for a “cheat sheet?” Find character pressure and character-building sheets in the resource shop!
Let the Details Do Some Heavy Lifting Too.
I think this is where writers, myself included, can sometimes get carried away.
We want readers to see the room, hear the conversation, understand the characters, and recognize what's at stake. So we keep adding information.
But more description doesn't necessarily make a scene richer.
Please don't make the living room curtains take center stage unless those curtains have something important to contribute.
Consider Lena pulling tape across an already sealed box. That small action gives us something to picture, but it also suggests she may be avoiding the conversation. The detail has more than one purpose.
And that's what I'm after when I talk about layers.
The physical setting, a character's private concerns, the history between people, and the ordinary things happening around them can all influence how a scene reads.
The trick is choosing details that belong naturally in the moment, rather than inserting them simply because they seem meaningful.
Not every object needs to symbolize something. Not every silence needs an explanation. Sometimes the reader can recognize tension without being told where it comes from.
Practice makes perfect progress.
Take a scene from something you're working on. Before adding another event or another paragraph of backstory, look at what's already happening.
What does your character want from this moment? What might they be thinking or feeling that they aren't saying? And what’s happening around them that could influence how they experience it?
Try changing just two or three details.
Then read the scene again.
You might find that the difference between a scene that feels thin and one that feels complete isn't how much you've written, but how much the writing allows the reader to understand.
Suggested Reading
Kevin Brockmeier, "The Ceiling"
Brockmeier uses the ordinary details of a child's birthday party to establish a world that gradually becomes extraordinary. Pay attention to the early images of the sky, birds, balloons, and things that fly, and how their significance changes as the story progresses.
Published in The Scribner Anthology of Contemporary Short Fiction: 50 North American Stories Since 1970, 2nd revised edition, pp. 93–102.